Quick Order
Fast Delivery

(305) 735-4566

South Island Pizza

Fresh. Hot. Island-made.

A better slice starts here.

Order Now
We make our dough in-house every day and let it rest overnight to develop the taste and structure it needs.
Our sauce is made fresh.
We shred cheese ourselves to get that perfect melt.
Pepperoni
Delux
Garlic Knots
Cheese
Specials For You

Popular Dishes

Delux Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Mango and Bacon Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
All Products
Fast Delivery

Your Favorite Pizza,

on the Way!

Enjoy the convenience of easy online ordering and quickdelivery.
Your meal is made fresh the moment you order — no heat lamps, no shortcuts.

Delivery in minutes

Fresh Ingredients

Family-Owned Local Spot

Fast Pickup

Hot, fresh, and ready when you arrive

Order Now
pizza-with-ingredients3.png
cola-with-ice-cubes-PSC8BDN.png
+
Top Choices

Best Pizza

Mango and Bacon
Pepperoni
Made to order
Made with Love

We Make the Best

Pizza in Town

At South Island Pizza & Grill, quality comes first.
Our dough is handcrafted, our toppings are fresh, and every pizza is baked with care by people who love great food as much as you do.

Join us for a slice (or a whole pie!) and taste why we’re becoming a local favorite.

  • Fresh Ingredients
  • Made Fresh Daily
  • Family-owned and Operated
About Us

Our dough is mixed, rested, and hand-stretched daily for the perfect texture — soft inside, crisp outside.

We use crisp veggies, premium meats, and quality cheeses to give every slice bold, delicious flavor.

Every pizza is prepared the moment you order it, ensuring hot, fresh, and flavorful results every time.

Handcrafted Dough

Fresh Toppings

Made to Order

Preparing the Pizzas

Gasper Oddo

Crafting Every Pie

South Island Pizza & Grill is a family-run restaurant in the heart of the Florida Keys. Every recipe, every pie, and every detail of our kitchen is built on a passion for great food and genuine hospitality.

We believe in keeping things simple — real ingredients, fresh dough, and flavors that bring people together.

Pizza, like every dish on the planet, is
only as good as the
ingredients.

Anthony Bianco
Order Online
Years in Business
0
Menu Items
0
5-Star Reviews
0
Pizzas Made Monthly
0 +
Lovely Memories

Our Best

Pizza Lovers.

All Reviews
Andrea Cannoy
Andrea Cannoy
" The best pizza on the island! Fermented for 72 hours it’s light, crispy, and no heartburn. I definitely recommend. The family that owns this place is awesome. "
Holly Perry
Holly Perry
" Very clean, welcoming place with attentive and friendly staff. Our pizza was ready in about ten minutes, which was a nice surprise. We got a 16" Margherita pizza. The crust is PERFECT. Crunchy and chewy... yum. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. We'll be back soon! Thank you! "
Tom Woods
Tom Woods
" Ordered a veggie to go. 10 to 15 minutes, fresh veggies, crisp not soggy. This is my pizza place now. Thank you. "
Asit Patel
Asit Patel@username
" The pizza was amazing! I loved the crust. It was light with a pleasant crunch on the surface but with a chewy consistency. We had the margarita pizza which was delicious and balanced. Definitely will be back for another. "
Jimmy Aurelio
Jimmy Aurelio@username
" South Island Pizza is awesome! I go here all the time and love that it’s a truly local spot — owned and operated by people who actually care about their customers. The staff is super friendly and you really get to know them. The sauce is amazing — tons of flavor and no heartburn (huge win!). Everything tastes fresh, and I literally saw the cook walk out to pick fresh basil for my pizza. How cool is that?! They’re always running great specials, and you have to try the Chicken Parm Pizza — absolutely superb. Easily my favorite pizza place around! 🍕🙌 "
Untitled design (3)
Untitled design (4)
Untitled design (5)
Untitled design (7)
Untitled design (8)
Untitled design (9)
Pickup or Delivery

Order Now!

Order Online